It’s high time for a new poll and today I wanted to follow on from the last poll. Natalie has now done three music videos. I’m sure you’ve all seen My Valentine but were you around when she did Dance Tonight and Carmensita?

If you’ve seen them all, I’d like to find out which one you think is the best.

Coming back to the My Valentine poll, it slayed almost half of you guys, while the other half were splintered into smaller camps. Those results are after the jump.

What did you think of the Paul McCartney music video, starring Natalie AND Johnny Depp?

It’s beautiful. Moving. Perfection. – 47.3% (88 votes)

It’s pretty to look at but lacking in substance. – 24.2% (45 votes)

I loved the Natalie only version. The other two – not so much. – 16.7% (31 votes)

It doesn’t earn the emotions. Cringe worthy. – 6.5% (12 votes)

Natalie is 0 for 3 with music videos. Give it up girl. – 5.4% (10 votes)